Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Robert McKee: Story: Style, Structure, Substance...
Christopher Vogler: The Writer's Journey: Mythic Structure for Writers
Shawn Coyne: The Story Grid: What Good Editors Know
John Yorke: Into the Woods: A Five-Act Journey Into Story
Larry Brooks: Story Physics and Story Engineering and Story Fix Larry Brooks

Lately I've been wooed into the left-brained world of editors and screenwriters writing about story structure. Studying these books (blogs, podcasts, presentations...) has helped me see my work's real flaws.

But because I'm more analytical than creative myself, I'm in danger of over-engineering my novel to fit a Grid, a set of Tent Poles, or a Hero's Journey. It's getting hard to tell whether I'm improving my story or ruining it.

A metaphor keeps springing to mind from a craft I'm more proficient in: sewing.

Let's suppose that the initial story inspiration is a beautiful length of cloth. The first draft is going to be a bit like linen-draping, where you shape the fabric with pins around a dressmaker's dummy.

(The dummy in this metaphor is story form. Chances are it will have two shoulders and one neck, be more or less laterally symmetrical, and have a recognizably human-ish shape--the bare minimum structure for the story-fabric to hang from. It's not a full mannequin.)

In subsequent drafts you start cutting and stitching, fitting and forming. At some point you might snip something that you can't seam up again, at least not without ruining the integrity of the particular story fabric, or of the garment you intended to make.

Now, gurus of story structure like those listed above tend to be white men in the corporate story world of TV, movie, and publishing, so it's not surprising that the guidelines they give are for tailoring a suit from wool gabardine around a one-size-fits-all mannequin. Mannequin. Ha ha.

Metaphorically, they say that a story needs sleeves to the wrist, legs to the instep, trousers/skirt to the waist, collar over the collarbones--a certain coverage, a certain fit, a certain degree of simplicity. Add or subtract an element at your peril: you might be creating something, but it won't be a suit.

But what if the cloth your story idea came to you in was crimson silk velvet, or beaded ivory chiffon, or Hawaiian print rayon? To honor that story idea, you're going to have to learn to trust the fabric quite a bit more than you trust The Rules.

Not that a Hawaiian print suit might not be kind of cool, because it totally would and now I can't stop picturing Alan Tudyk wearing it, but he probably wouldn't wear it to the boardroom. It would be, in effect, pajamas.

If your story presents itself as four yards of a leis-and-ukuleles on silky rayon, maybe it wants you to write it in more of a holoku style. Relaxed, warm, flowing, graceful, fun:

Pegge Hopper print of a Hawaiian woman in a holoku dress

And as soon as you put "crimson velvet" and "suit" together in a sentence, you're sewing for Little Lord Fauntleroy, or else for the Elizabethan stage. Either way, there's going to be some extra fabric, some big sleeves or slashing or frog closures; some padding, gold braid, maybe a codpiece. Maybe that story wants to be written to a richer, perhaps bloodier, perhaps more princely pattern.

Crimson velvet Elizabethan doublet

And as for beaded ivory chiffon! I can't even get to "suit" in the context of beaded ivory chiffon. That story wants to be an evening gown in waltz time, or some fabulous drag drapery--either way, it wants to be light, floaty, extravagant (or Grace Kelly cool) but it's gonna break some structural rules, and it certainly won't be a suit.

Fabulous off-white chiffon ruffled duster

The suit-men listed at the top of this post want me to write something that will sell--that they themselves would acquire. Nothing wrong with that. But now that I've spent a year absorbing their rules, I really need to start breaking them.

A couple of creativity gurus who might approve of stories constructed as fabulous chiffon dusters or Magnum's PJs:

Big Magic: Creative Living Beyond Fear Elizabeth Gilbert
The War of Art Steven Pressfield

Crossposted from Dreamwidth, where there are comment count unavailable comments.


( 3 comments — Leave a comment )
Jan. 8th, 2016 07:06 am (UTC)
Unfortunately, I can't see your images, but I think I get what you're saying anyhow. I don't think you're ruining your story by rewriting it but you are creating a different book than the Restraint I read a while back. That's not bad unless it feels bad to the Creator (you).

All these book writers are telling you what worked for them but that doesn't mean that what works for you isn't just as valid.

Jan. 8th, 2016 11:13 am (UTC)
I can't see your pictures, either, but I like the way you're putting this together. Of course, the bit that's missing from this metaphor is: who will wear the clothes? Are you designing a one-off bespoke piece of couture, or an off-the-rack machine-sewn garment? Are you sewing a one-size-fits-all, or are you designing something that will look good in any size, for any shape? Are you designing something that will only suit curve-less androgynes on the catwalk, or something you could expect real people to wear? Are you designing something functional, to be worn, or are you designing art, to be admired?

Not that you can't design something that's both. There is, of course, a place for all of these garments in fashion, just as there is a place for all of these works in literature.

Not, of course, that I'm intending to complicate your metaphor.
Jan. 15th, 2016 01:02 am (UTC)
Keep the soul of the book! And the energy.
( 3 comments — Leave a comment )



Latest Month

December 2018


Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow